Share from 0:00
0:00
/

Forever Straniero | A Live Conversation with Barbara Rocci

On being a foreigner by choice, why I write about a thousand towns nobody visits, and the handful of grumpy Italians I have met.

Barbara - Timetobeitalian started by admitting she had read my bio wrong. It says Forever straniero, and she had taken it as a complaint, the foreigner who never gets let in. I told her it was closer to the opposite. I explained this concept in one of my latest issues here.

The phrase goes back to high school. I grew up in a small town in Hungary, and in the mid-nineties I won a Soros scholarship that sent me to the United States for a month. One day I was a teenager in the Hungarian provinces and the next I was standing in Atlanta airport in the middle of the American nineties, and I do not think I ever fully came back.

After that I was always looking for the place with the most freedom in it, which is also where the Anywhere in the name comes from. London came first, years of advertising work, then Budapest again, where I found out how hard it is to return to a country you have left. I said it on the live and I will say it here, with apologies to anyone reading from Hungary: I never felt at home in my own country. My work has had no fixed address for a decade. A life like that makes you a foreigner everywhere, and I have stopped minding. Lately I think I prefer it.

Barbara asked what brought me to Italy, since most of the foreigners she talks to have an Italian grandparent somewhere. I have none, and I do not think anyone needs a justification for living here. What I could tell her is that it was never a decision. It began in 2021 with two months, which became three, then half a year with regular trips back to the apartment in Budapest, then a rental contract in Tuscany, and now we own a home here. You emigrate to England in one move, with a job and a suitcase. Italy takes you in by instalments.

She asked what Italians take for granted, given how much they complain. My answer may sound arrogant. I pay taxes here and I own a front door, and I am still an outsider, a first-generation immigrant whose income does not depend on Italy at all. I follow the politics closely, because I studied history and sociology and worked as a journalist and cannot help it. But most of what Italians complain about is not my problem, and I would rather say so plainly.

Then the thousand towns. We lived in Versilia for years and went to the Cinque Terre often, but only in January and February, sometimes March. In July and August we left our own home and went elsewhere. I am not against visitors; a lot of towns, especially in the South, are kept alive by travelers and their money. Past a certain point, though, it stops being about money and starts eating the local way of life. If I can talk one person into ten other towns in place of the usual ones, I have done something small for both sides.

The idea came from a week in Ronciglione, in Lazio, near Lake Vico, on the old Via Francigena. There is not much to do in Ronciglione, and I say that with affection. There was a villa with a pool you could walk into for ten euros. We lay beside it. We went to the lake. That week changed how I travel.

Read that article here:

Barbara asked about the two most worn-out words in Italian travel, hidden and authentic. As a marketer I told her they are excellent for Google. As a writer I cannot stand either. The towns on the lists of hidden towns are not hidden. The hidden ones are places like Barga, in the mountains behind the Tuscan coast, where families who emigrated to Scotland generations ago keep coming back, and where the town holds a Scottish music festival, bagpipes included. As for authentic: authentic to whom? I know what a Tuscan is, and a Venetian, and someone from Perugia. I am less sure what an Italian is. One of Barbara’s students once compared the country to a lasagna, all layers. I said at least they are cooked in the same pot.

What has Italy changed in me? It slowed me down, and it gave me no choice in the matter. The population is among the oldest in the world, and the state moves at the same age. Even Turin, where I live now, a big city of old aristocratic money and working families who came up from Calabria and Puglia, runs slower than anything I knew in London in my thirties. The Turinese are reserved. The southerners will be your friend in ten minutes. I like having both on the same street.

She closed by asking for something to watch. I said the Italian films of the seventies and eighties, most of which English speakers misread. The Fellini film with the Trevi Fountain is about a bored elite and a pointless emptiness, and its title became a slogan for the good life. My own favorite is Cinema Paradiso, for the ending.

Then I said something I had not planned to say. Hungarians, and I am allowed to say this, are mostly grumpy or reserved. In all my years here I can count on one hand the Italians who were unpleasant to me. Everyone else, whatever their salary or their politics, met me with the same openness. On the live I called it joy of life and apologised for how it sounded. I am not apologising here.

Barbara writes Barbara - Timetobeitalian. Sign up to Barbara’s newsletter here:

Discussion about this video

User's avatar